Claim: Katniss consistently underestimates her competitors in the Hunger Games.
Quote: Katniss describes Rue as a “small yellow flower” (Collins 99).
What Makes Strong Reasoning?
Authors use reasoning to explain how their evidence supports their claim.
Strong reasoning
- draws a conclusion from the evidence and
- supports the claim.
Example
|
Strong Reasoning
|
The word “small,” as well as the comparison to a delicate flower, shows that Katniss does not think Rue will be a tough competitor. |
|
Weak Reasoning: Not Connected to the Claim
|
Katniss’s description shows that she feels protective of young Rue. |
|
Weak Reasoning: Not Connected to the Evidence
|
Katniss’s arrogance lands her in several dangerous situations. |
|
More Evidence, Not Reasoning
|
Katniss says that twelve-year-old Rue reminds her of a bird (Collins 99). |